Gifting shares in a family investment company can trigger more tax than expected if the valuation is wrong. As Aman Bhardwaj from DNS Accountants explains, the value attributed to shares, especially where different share classes are introduced, can have significant capital gains tax and inheritance tax consequences

Why does valuation matter?
When shares are sold between independent parties on an arm’s length basis, the amount agreed will usually determine the tax position.
On the other hand, when shares are gifted to children, transferred into a family trust or reorganised within a family investment company (FIC), the position is different.
For capital gains tax (CGT), transactions between connected persons are subjected to market value even where no money changes hands.
Inheritance tax (IHT) also uses market value, but with an important distinction. Under section 3 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984, the value transferred is based on the reduction in the donor’s estate rather than simply the value of the shares gifted.
For example, a parent who owns 100% of a company might gift 30% to a family trust. The IHT value transferred may exceed 30% of the company’s value, because the remaining 70% holding could be worth less than its proportionate share of the whole company.
The distinction becomes important when deciding how many shares can be transferred within the available IHT allowances.
How are shares in a family investment company valued?
Unlike a trading company, where valuation may depend on turnover, profits and future earnings, a FIC holding investment properties or financial investments will most of the time be valued by reference to its net assets.
This involves considering the market value of its investments, liabilities and potential tax liabilities.
Nonetheless, valuing the company is only the starting point. The value of an individual shareholding will also depend on the voting rights, dividend rights, capital rights, restrictions on transfers and the shareholder’s ability to influence company decisions.
A minority shareholding may attract a discount because the shareholder may have limited influence over company decisions, no control over when dividends are declared and very little ability to sell their shares to an outside purchaser.
Further, the discounts are not fixed percentages and depend on the rights attached to the shares and the circumstances of the company being valued.
Growth shares and the importance of the hurdle
Growth shares are frequently considered when parents wish to retain the existing value of a family investment company while allowing future growth to pass to their children or a family trust.
In the most common structure, the parents retain shares with rights to the company’s existing value, while a new class of growth shares participates only when the company’s value exceeds a specified amount, known as the ‘hurdle’.
For example, consider a FIC currently worth £5 million.
The parents retain shares representing the existing value while growth shares are issued to a family trust with an entitlement to value above £6 million (20% hurdle).
If the company subsequently increases in value to £8 million, the growth shares may participate in £2 million of that value.
Yet, setting a £6 million hurdle does not mean the growth shares have no value when issued.
A prospective purchaser would consider the likelihood of the company exceeding the hurdle, the period over which growth might occur, expected investment returns and the rights attached to the shares.
Even where the current company value is below the hurdle, the opportunity to benefit from future appreciation has economic value.
This is an area where HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation team may challenge the valuation adopted.
Advisers should therefore establish the appropriate hurdle using a commercially supportable valuation, rather than selecting an arbitrary amount intended to produce a negligible share value.
Depending on the circumstances, valuation techniques may include discounted cash flow, probability-weighted outcomes or option pricing models. For this reason, a specialist valuation should be obtained before the articles are finalised, not after the shares have been issued.
What to agree before the shares are issued
For private client solicitors advising on FICs, family trusts and succession planning, the articles of association are particularly important.
Before the shares are issued or transferred, the following matters should be agreed:
- an independent valuation of the company and of each share class
- the hurdle at which growth shares begin participating
- whether the hurdle applies to dividends, capital distributions or both
- the voting, dividend and winding-up rights of each share class
- any restrictions on share transfers and future share issues
- whether the proposed arrangements could alter the value of existing shareholdings.
The valuation and legal documentation must reflect the same commercial arrangement. Where the rights are unclear, HMRC may adopt a different valuation from what was originally intended.
A final consideration
Growth shares and family investment companies can be useful succession planning tools, allowing existing wealth and future growth to be treated differently.
However, the tax outcome depends on the actual value and rights of the shares, not simply the description given to them.
A properly supported valuation, alongside carefully drafted articles, is therefore an essential part of the planning.